Chelsea Handler condemns jokes at Kevin Hart roast, drawing backlash and sarcastic response from Shane Gillis
Comedian Chelsea Handler criticized jokes by Shane Gillis and Tony Hinchcliffe during the recent Netflix roast of Kevin Hart, calling them racist, sexist, and gross—particularly a lynching joke by Gillis and a suicide-related joke about Sheryl Underwood’s late husband. Handler stated that such topics cross ethical lines, even in comedy. Gillis responded sarcastically through his representative, wishing her success and promoting his tour. Underwood defended the joke about her husband, saying humor helped her process grief and encouraged mental health conversations. The roast continues Netflix’s trend of edgy, no-holds-barred comedy, sparking debate over the boundaries of humor. Handler’s past attendance at a Jeffrey Epstein event was referenced by Gillis during the roast, a topic she previously addressed in a 2021 interview.
Fox News provides the most balanced and complete coverage, including key quotes, context about the roast tradition, and space for multiple perspectives. New York Post is highly opinionated and uses polemical framing to discredit Handler. New York Post is factually rich but leans into feud narrative and includes politically charged labels without critical distance. All sources agree on core facts, but differ significantly in tone, emphasis, and framing.
- ✓ Chelsea Handler criticized jokes made by Shane Gillis and Tony Hinchcliffe at the Kevin Hart Netflix roast.
- ✓ Handler specifically objected to Gillis’ joke about lynching Kevin Hart, referencing his height, and Hinchcliffe’s joke about Sheryl Underwood’s late husband’s suicide.
- ✓ Handler described the jokes as 'gross,' 'racist,' 'sexist,' and said 'lynching Black people is not a joke' and that it is 'worse than rape.'
- ✓ Gillis responded sarcastically through his representative, saying, 'This is a big moment for Chelsea. I am glad she’s capitalizing. Good for her. We’re all rooting for her.'
- ✓ The roast event occurred recently and was part of Netflix’s recent series of high-profile, edgy roasts, including one of Tom Brady in 2024.
- ✓ Sheryl Underwood defended the joke about her late husband, saying humor provided catharsis and opened a conversation about mental health, particularly among Black men.
- ✓ Gillis made a joke referencing Chelsea Handler’s past attendance at an event hosted by Jeffrey Epstein during the roast.
- ✓ Handler discussed her attendance at the Epstein event in a 2021 interview with Rob Lowe, saying she didn’t know who he was at the time and found it awkward.
Framing of Handler’s motivation and credibility
Presents Handler’s criticism neutrally as part of public discourse, focusing more on Gillis’ response and the broader context of roast comedy. Does not question her motives.
Acknowledges Handler’s criticism but includes Gillis’ counter-jabs and her past Epstein association without overtly judging her, though the inclusion of political labels ('Zionist', 'abortion fan') may subtly frame her as polarizing.
Tone toward Gillis and Hinchcliffe
Neutral and reportorial. Describes Gillis’ joke as controversial but notes his reflection that it 'could have done without it' and was told to 'the wrong crowd.'
Slightly sympathetic to Gillis, highlighting his comeback and framing the exchange as a 'feud,' but also reports his self-critique of the joke.
Treatment of Sheryl Underwood’s response
Mentions Underwood’s defense briefly but neutrally.
Includes Underwood’s defense and quotes her directly, presenting it as a legitimate counterpoint.
Use of Handler’s past comedy and persona
Mentions she is an 'outspoken liberal entertainer' but does not dwell on her comedic past or past controversies.
Notes her past Epstein association and includes Gillis’ on-stage jabs but does not editorialize on her comedic history.
New York Post
Framing: New York Post frames the event as a hypocrisy scandal, portraying Handler as a self-righteous, out-of-touch figure who violates comedy’s sacred tradition of offensive humor. The roast is positioned as a cultural reset, and Handler’s criticism is dismissed as moral panic.
Tone: polemical, mocking, and dismissive
Narrative Framing: Describes Handler as 'petty and hypocritical' and a 'white savior,' implying moral grandstanding. This is a clear case of narrative framing that positions her as an outsider imposing values.
"Chelsea Handler suddenly found a set of pearls to clutch."
Loaded Language: Refers to Handler as 'abrasive abortion enthusiast'—a politically loaded term not relevant to the event, used to discredit her.
"the abrasive abortion enthusiast has deputized herself the head of the Joke Police"
Sensationalism: Dismisses Underwood’s approval of the joke with sarcasm: 'who cares how she feels,' undermining Handler’s moral argument by contrasting it with the actual affected party’s response.
"Underwood was fine with it, but who cares how she feels."
Cherry-Picking: Suggests Handler took 'the check' and sought 'center stage,' implying financial and attention-seeking motives without evidence.
"Despite it all being so icky, Handler took the check and the opportunity to be center stage."
Framing by Emphasis: Frames the Tom Brady roast as a 'watershed moment' that 'washed away' the 'woke era,' implying a cultural shift that Handler opposes. This is ideological framing.
"The Netflix roast of Tom Brady in 2024 was a real watershed moment, washing away all the residual gunk from our hypersensitive woke era."
Fox News
Framing: Fox News frames the event as a public dispute between comedians, focusing on Gillis’ response and the broader context of roast comedy. It treats both sides as participants in a comedic culture war without overt judgment.
Tone: neutral, reportorial, and contextual
Proper Attribution: Reports Gillis’ response verbatim and includes his reflection on the joke’s reception, showing nuance and proper attribution.
"Gillis in particular made jokes about slavery and lyn游戏副本... He later said of this joke on his podcast that he 'could have done without it'"
Balanced Reporting: Describes Handler as an 'outspoken liberal entertainer' without editorializing, maintaining neutral tone.
"Handler, an outspoken liberal entertainer, recently made waves for condemning certain jokes"
Comprehensive Sourcing: Includes Handler’s provocative quote about being 'rich, famous, and hot' without judgment, allowing readers to interpret.
"I'm rich, I'm famous, and I'm hot. So, I'm f---ing people."
Comprehensive Sourcing: Mentions the Epstein joke but presents it as part of the roast dynamic, not as a moral indictment.
"The most viral roast of her at the event, however, was Gillis making fun of her past association with deceased, disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein."
New York Post
Framing: New York Post frames the event as a celebrity feud, emphasizing conflict and retaliation. It includes key facts but leans into sensational elements like political labels and personal attacks.
Tone: sensational, conflict-oriented, and slightly biased toward Gillis
Narrative Framing: Describes the exchange as a 'feud,' which dramatizes the conflict and adds narrative tension.
"further escalating their feud"
Loaded Language: Includes Gillis’ jab calling Handler a 'Zionist' and 'big fan of abortions,' which are politically charged labels presented without critique or context.
"He even took aim at her political stances, calling her a 'Zionist' and a 'big fan of abortions.'"
Balanced Reporting: Reports Underwood’s defense of Hinchcliffe but does not emphasize its significance in challenging Handler’s stance.
"Underwood defended Hinchcliffe’s wisecrack... 'Sometimes humor is the thing.'"
Vague Attribution: Cites Handler’s explanation of the Epstein event but only in passing, potentially minimizing its relevance.
"Handler previously addressed her attendance at Epstein’s controversial party..."
Shane Gillis takes jab at Chelsea Handler after she slammed his ‘gross,’ ‘racist’ jokes at Kevin Hart roast
Shane Gillis shrugs off, mocks Chelsea Handler's outrage over his jokes at Kevin Hart roast
Chelsea Handler isn’t just petty and hypocritical — now she thinks she’s a white savior