New NTSB data suggests intentional cockpit actions led to 2022 China Eastern Airlines crash
SUMMARY
Newly released data from the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) indicates that the 2022 crash of China Eastern Flight 5735, which killed all 132 people on board, involved deliberate actions in the cockpit. The flight data recorder shows both engines were intentionally shut down mid-flight, followed by a nosedive and at least one full roll. Back-and-forth movements of the control wheels suggest a struggle between two individuals. The NTSB assisted the investigation due to the U.S.-made aircraft and engines. While the data points to intentional action, the cockpit voice recorder transcript has not been released by Chinese authorities, and China’s final investigation report remains pending more than four years after the crash. Some sources report additional claims about audio evidence of a struggle, but these are not independently corroborated.
The headline and summary are AI-generated to reduce bias
New NTSB data suggests intentional cockpit actions led to 2022 China Eastern Airlines crash
SUMMARY
Newly released data from the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) indicates that the 2022 crash of China Eastern Flight 5735, which killed all 132 people on board, involved deliberate actions in the cockpit. The flight data recorder shows both engines were intentionally shut down mid-flight, followed by a nosedive and at least one full roll. Back-and-forth movements of the control wheels suggest a struggle between two individuals. The NTSB assisted the investigation due to the U.S.-made aircraft and engines. While the data points to intentional action, the cockpit voice recorder transcript has not been released by Chinese authorities, and China’s final investigation report remains pending more than four years after the crash. Some sources report additional claims about audio evidence of a struggle, but these are not independently corroborated.
The headline and summary are AI-generated to reduce bias
The sources broadly agree on the core technical findings but diverge significantly in framing, completeness, and inclusion of unverified claims. ABC News provides the most balanced and technically detailed account. Daily Mail stands out for introducing sensational, uncorroborated details. NZ Herald adds political context absent elsewhere. The lack of a final Chinese report continues to shape media interpretation.
Data suggests struggle in cockpit before deadly China Eastern plane crash
Article Framing: NZ Herald frames the event within a broader context of Chinese state secrecy and information suppression. The crash is presented not just as an aviation incident but as a politically sensitive event.
Tone: Politically aware and critical of opacity. It emphasizes institutional silence and censorship.
New data on 2022 China plane crash suggests cockpit struggle and fuel cut
Article Framing: ABC News frames the event as a technically complex investigation with deliberate actions likely, but emphasizes uncertainty due to missing Chinese data. It presents the evidence methodically and avoids definitive conclusions.
Tone: Analytical, cautious, and technically detailed. It prioritizes factual reporting and acknowledges gaps in information.
Data Suggests Struggle in Cockpit Before Deadly China Eastern Plane Crash
Article Framing: The New York Times frames the crash similarly to Irish Times — as a deliberate act following a cockpit struggle — with a formal, authoritative tone.
Tone: Formal and authoritative. It reads like a major news wire service, relying on expert quotes and official data.
more event articles by score ↓ collapse ↑
New data suggests struggle in cockpit before deadly Boeing 737 plane crash
Article Framing: Irish Times frames the crash as a deliberate act following a cockpit struggle, emphasizing the technical data and expert interpretation. It avoids political or institutional critique.
Tone: Confident and narrative-driven. It presents a clear cause-effect story with minimal uncertainty.
18-second 'fight' in cockpit of death-plunge Boeing jet: Recordings 'reveal screams, rows and rapid breathing during battle over controls' as plane nosedived leaving 132 dead in China
Article Framing: Daily Mail frames the crash as a dramatic, violent struggle with human audio evidence. It prioritizes sensational details over technical or institutional context.
Tone: Sensational and dramatic. It reads more like tabloid reporting, emphasizing conflict and emotion.
ADVANCED ANALYSIS
WHAT SOURCES AGREE ON
1 / 6- ✓ All sources agree that new data from the NTSB, released via a public records or FOIA request, suggests intentional actions led to the 2022 China Eastern Airlines crash.
- ✓ There is agreement that both engines were deliberately shut down mid-flight by cutting off fuel.
- ✓ All sources cite Jeff Guzzetti, a former NTSB/FAA investigator, interpreting the flight data as indicating aggressive, intentional control inputs.
- ✓ The flight data shows the plane entered a nosedive and at least one 360-degree roll.
- ✓ The back-and-forth movement of cockpit controls suggests a struggle between two individuals.
- ✓ The crash killed all 132 people on board China Eastern Flight 5735, which was en route from Kunming to Guangzhou.
- ✓ The NTSB assisted in the investigation due to the U.S. origin of the Boeing 737 and its engines.
- ✓ China has not yet released its final investigation report more than four years after the crash.
ABC News
Daily Mail
Irish Times
NZ Herald
The New York Times
Daily Mail
ABC News
Irish Times
NZ Herald
The New York Times
ABC News
NZ Herald
Irish Times
Daily Mail
The New York Times
ABC News
Daily Mail
Irish Times
NZ Herald
The New York Times
ABC News
Irish Times
NZ Herald
Daily Mail
The New York Times
Data suggests struggle in cockpit before deadly China Eastern plane crash
New data on 2022 China plane crash suggests cockpit struggle and fuel cut
Data Suggests Struggle in Cockpit Before Deadly China Eastern Plane Crash
New data suggests struggle in cockpit before deadly Boeing 737 plane crash
18-second 'fight' in cockpit of death-plunge Boeing jet: Recordings 'reveal screams, rows and rapid breathing during battle over controls' as plane nosedived leaving 132 dead in China