Transgender Community
Date Range
Score Range
New York Post (Safe / Threatened) : North Carolina school ignored complaints about trans student staring at girls in locker room: filing
Portraying transgender individuals as a threat to others' safety and privacy
[loaded_language], [sensationalism]: The headline and quotes frame the transgender student’s presence as inherently violating and dangerous to girls.
“North Carolina school ignored complaints about trans student staring at girls in locker room: filing”
ABC News (Included / Excluded) : The European Commission seeks to ban gay 'conversion therapy'
Transgender individuals explicitly included in protections, countering marginalization
[framing_by_emphasis]: Though headline says 'gay', the body clarifies the ban covers gender identity, affirming transgender people as part of the protected group despite potential erasure in public discourse.
“The EU's Agency for Fundamental Rights said in 2024 that one in four LGTBQ+ citizens polled had been subjected to the scientifically discredited practice to attempt to change their sexual orientation or gender identity.”
Fox News (Ally / Adversary) : California girls' track and field stars speak out as Gavin Newsom's Title IX crisis grows
Transgender athletes are framed as adversaries in girls' sports, despite claims of non-personal opposition
Although athletes state they are not targeting individuals, the use of 'biological females' and descriptions of unfair advantage position trans athletes as intrinsically disruptive to fairness.
“if only biological females were allowed to compete”
The New York Times (Included / Excluded) : Student Is Fatally Stabbed in University of Washington Housing Complex
Affirms inclusion and acknowledges specific vulnerability of transgender individuals in the context of violence
[balanced_reporting] (severity 10/10): The article reports the victim’s identity as a transgender woman factually and includes the university president’s statement recognizing added distress when LGBTQIA+ members are affected, signaling validation and inclusion.
“While investigators have not yet identified a suspect or a motive, I want to recognize that when violence affects a member of our L.G.B.T.Q.I.A.+ community, it can cause additional distress.”
The New York Times (Included / Excluded) : Former Congressman Barney Frank, Now in Hospice, Offers Democrats Frank Words of Advice
framed as being strategically excluded to protect broader political gains
Frank advises delaying advocacy on trans rights in sports, comparing it to the delayed push for same-sex marriage, implying current demands risk alienating the public and excluding trans issues from mainstream acceptance.
“I analogize that to male-to-female transgender sports. That is the most controversial part of the agenda — the equivalent of gay marriage — so put it at the end.”
CBC (Included / Excluded) : Trump order impacting gender-affirming care at McGill student clinic, trans rights group says
framed as being excluded from essential healthcare based on nationality and gender identity
[framing_by_emphasis] and [omission]: The article emphasizes that U.S. trans students under 19 are being denied care at McGill due to U.S. policy fears, highlighting exclusion. The lack of institutional confirmation amplifies the perception of covert marginalization.
“They said they wouldn't be prescribing HRT to American citizens who were under 19 because of the executive order that Donald Trump issued”
The Guardian (Ally / Adversary) : ‘It’s like a trans-Barbie world!’: the Indian festival where transgender women can celebrate without fear
The state is framed as an adversary to trans people through legal and bureaucratic control
The framing positions state institutions as actively undermining trans lives through law and documentation practices.
“It is like the state is trying to say that we do not exist, that we are not visible. But we are here. We have always been here since history. And our history cannot be erased simply.”
The Guardian (Included / Excluded) : ‘It’s like a trans-Barbie world!’: the Indian festival where transgender women can celebrate without fear
Trans women are portrayed as finally included and visible in a space of their own
The article centers trans voices and emphasizes their temporary liberation from societal exclusion, using emotive personal testimony to highlight belonging.
“For once, we are the majority. We are everywhere – in the streets, in the shops, in each other’s lives. I can just exist with my trans sisters without explaining myself.”
New York Post (Included / Excluded) : California misses the memo on transgender athletes
framed as excluded and unwelcome in women's sports
The article repeatedly emphasizes that transgender women do not belong in female sports categories, using exclusionary language and portraying their participation as an unfair intrusion.
“But they should not do so at the expense of other athletes who deserve a level playing field.”
Fox News (Included / Excluded) : Georgia Pride group recruiting kids as young as 13 into drag shows sparks backlash
Transgender community and allies portrayed as outsiders pushing boundaries on child-appropriate spaces
By referencing past events like 'No Easter without the T' and emphasizing children's participation in drag, the article frames transgender-affirming cultural activities as invasive and inappropriate, reinforcing exclusionary narratives.
“Last year, another drag queen group, the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, a self-described "order of queer and trans nuns," sparked backlash for an event, "No Easter without the T," to honor transgender people where they held a children’s Easter egg hunt and a costume contest asking attendees to dress in drag as "Hunky Jesus and Foxy Mary."”