SNP
Date Range
Score Range
Irish Times (Effective / Failing) : The money demands of nationalist parties in Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland could backfire – The …
SNP is framed as avoiding difficult decisions and relying on external blame
The article implies the SNP is strategically avoiding reform by retaining a flawed funding formula, suggesting poor governance and lack of long-term planning.
“Scotland chose not to adopt the needs-based formula after setting up its own expert commission in 2009. The old system it is retaining, known as the Barnett formula, contains a flaw called the Barnett squeeze that will slowly drive Scotland’s funding down to the same level as England. This effect is so gradual the SNP thinks it is better to stick with it.”
Daily Mail (Ally / Adversary) : Nigel Farage calls Reform 'largest unionist party in the country' and says they will be …
SNP framed as a separatist adversary threatening national unity
The article consistently pairs SNP with Plaid Cymru under the label 'separatists' and presents their governance as part of a dangerous trend toward breakup, without offering their perspective or policy context.
“tackling threat from separatists like SNP and Plaid Cymru”
Daily Mail (Effective / Failing) : Swinney just won't take no for an answer as he launches ANOTHER bid to break …
portrayed as failing due to loss of votes and seats, undermining competence
Cherry-picking and framing by emphasis highlight electoral losses while downplaying continued parliamentary strength, suggesting organizational failure.
“His party lost six seats and ended up with 58 MSPs – seven short of the number required to achieve a majority - as Scots voted tactically to try and oust the nationalists.”
Daily Mail (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Donald Trump congratulates John Swinney on re-election in Scotland and praises him for winning whisky …
portrayed as making exaggerated claims to legitimacy
narrative_fram grinding
“the SNP subsequently claimed the removal of whisky tariffs was evidence of the First Minister 'delivering' for Scotland, saying: 'John Swinney fought for Scotch whisky. And he delivered.'”
RTÉ (Effective / Failing) : SNP to emerge as largest party in Scottish parliament
SNP portrayed as politically effective and dominant
[framing_by_emphasis], [cherry_picking] — The article emphasizes SNP gains and Swinney’s confident statements while omitting discussion of potential losses or lack of majority, framing the party as electorally strong and effective.
“The SNP also won the Eastwood constituency outside of Glasgow from the Scottish Tories...”
BBC News (Effective / Failing) : SNP wins Scottish election as Reform and Labour tie for second
SNP portrayed as resilient and dominant despite failing to win majority
[framing_by_emphasis], [loaded_language]
“The SNP has defied political gravity by winning a fifth consecutive term in office.”
Daily Mail (Ally / Adversary) : Humiliation for Labour in Scotland as Sarwar admits defeat
framed as a dominant political force overcoming opponents
The narrative positions the SNP as capitalising on Labour’s weakness and 'swiping' seats, using adversarial language that frames them as aggressive victors in a political contest.
“In the biggest upset of this election so far, the SNP swiped Shetland from the Liberal Democrats - a constituency Mr Swinney's party has long-targeted but has been held by the Libs for nearly 30 years.”
BBC News (Ally / Adversary) : Scottish election results: Six things to watch out for
framed as a confrontational force pushing independence
[framing_by_emphasis] and [cherry_picking]: The article repeatedly centers the SNP's push for a majority as a disruptive, high-stakes objective, particularly in relation to forcing another independence referendum, which is framed as a contentious act against UK opposition.
“If the SNP does win a majority, we enter a whole other discussion about mandates and the UK government's ongoing opposition to a fresh independence poll.”
The Guardian (Stable / Crisis) : ‘I am losing faith’: disaffected Scottish voters may deny SNP a fifth term
SNP campaign framed as being in crisis and under significant pressure
[loaded_language] and [framing_by_emphasis]: The phrase 'gravity-defying fifth term' implies implausibility and exceptional strain, while the focus on declining poll ratings and internal nervousness reinforces a crisis narrative.
“Even as the SNP heads towards a gravity-defying fifth term in office”
The Guardian (Effective / Failing) : ‘I am losing faith’: disaffected Scottish voters may deny SNP a fifth term
SNP portrayed as losing effectiveness and failing to address core voter concerns
[framing_by_emphasis] and [cherry_picking]: The article emphasizes voter anger and disillusionment with the SNP through multiple personal stories, while omitting positive supporter experiences or policy enthusiasm. This selective focus frames the party as underperforming.
“I do believe in the SNP but I am losing faith vastly”