Palestinian Authority
Date Range
Score Range
The New York Times (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Aging Palestinian Leader Boosting His Son’s Political Rise, Officials Say
framing the Palestinian Authority as lacking democratic legitimacy
The article repeatedly emphasizes that Abbas's term ended in 2009 and that elections have been canceled for 20 years, while highlighting dynastic succession efforts. This framing undermines the institution's legitimacy without counterbalancing claims of legitimacy from supporters.
“Mr. Abbas’s presidential term technically ended in 2009, but he has since canceled elections.”
Reuters (Included / Excluded) : Federal judge blocks US sanctions against UN expert on Palestinian territories
Palestinian cause is framed as deserving international protection and voice
[framing_by_emphasis], [cherry_picking]
“U.N. expert on the Palestinian territories”
CTV News (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Israeli bulldozers raze about 50 Palestinian shops ahead of settlement-linked road project
Palestinian Authority portrayed as a credible counter-narrative source
The article quotes the Palestinian Authority’s interpretation of the road project as part of a broader segregation plan, presenting their view without skepticism or counter-attribution, enhancing their credibility.
“The Palestinian Authority says the demolitions are connected to Israel’s plans to overhaul transportation and build a tunnel and bypass road to reroute Palestinian traffic off a major Israeli highway linking nearby settlements to Jerusalem and cutting them off from large swaths of the West Bank.”
ABC News (Stable / Crisis) : Surfers in war-torn Gaza find rare moments of joy taking to the waves
Palestinian governance and societal stability framed as in crisis due to war and displacement
[framing_by_emphasis] and [omission]: The article opens with the 'dire humanitarian crisis' and widespread destruction, emphasizing collapse rather than governance or recovery efforts.
“Palestinians continue to struggle to secure food, clean water, medical care and shelter after the war caused widespread destruction, dismantled healthcare infrastructure and displaced most of the territory’s residents.”
CBC (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Loyalists of President Abbas win big in Palestinian municipal elections
Portrayed as legitimate authority pursuing democratic renewal
The article emphasizes the PA's role in organizing elections after a long hiatus, especially in Gaza, framing it as a step toward national unity and democratic legitimacy despite low turnout and boycotts.
“Abbas's West Bank-based Palestinian Authority (PA) said the inclusion of the Gaza city Deir al-Balah, which suffered less damage than other areas of the coastal territory during the war, was intended to show that Gaza was an inseparable part of a future Palestinian state.”
RNZ (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Palestinian local elections give some Gazans first chance to vote in years
Framed as having legitimate authority over Gaza
The article emphasizes the Palestinian Authority's narrative that including Gaza in elections affirms national unity and legitimacy, despite limited control. It quotes President Abbas asserting Gaza as an 'inseparable part of the state of Palestine' and frames the vote as reinforcing PA authority.
“Gaza is an inseparable part of the state of Palestine. Therefore, we have worked by all means to ensure that elections take place in Deir al-Balah to affirm the unity of the two parts of the country together”
ABC News (Effective / Failing) : Local elections in the West Bank and part of Gaza could test public trust
Framed as making incremental progress through reform
[proper_attribution], [comprehensive_sourcing]
“The Palestinian Authority has promoted the local races following reforms it enacted last year after demands from international backers.”
NBC News (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Local elections in the West Bank and part of Gaza could test public trust
Framing the Palestinian Authority as a legitimate political actor despite constraints
[framing_by_emphasis] and [comprehensive_sourcing]: The article emphasizes the PA's reform efforts and promotion of elections as a response to international demands, attributing agency and legitimacy to the institution.
“Though it has not held presidential or legislative elections since 2006, the Palestinian Authority promoted the local races after reforms it enacted last year in response to demands from international backers.”
TheJournal.ie (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Palestinians vote in local elections in the West Bank and Gaza
framing the Palestinian Authority as lacking legitimacy
[framing_by_emphasis], [cherry_picking], [omission]
“The Palestinian Authority faces widespread criticism over corruption, stagnation and declining legitimacy.”
BBC News (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Palestinians in West Bank and some in Gaza vote in local elections
Framing the Palestinian Authority as the legitimate political authority by endorsing its electoral process
[framing_by_emphasis] and [cherry_picking] — The article emphasizes the symbolic significance of holding elections in Gaza for the first time since 2006, while downplaying the lack of competition and participation, implicitly legitimizing the PA-led process.
“including the first poll of any kind to be held in Gaza since 2006”