Québec Solidaire
Date Range
Score Range
CTV News (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Québec solidaire weighing priorities, including wealth tax and public grocery stores
The party is framed as offering legitimate, evidence-based responses to public concerns
[proper_attribution], [comprehensive_sourcing]
“Some 350 party members are gathered in Montreal this weekend to adopt positions on the cost of living, affordability and wealth redistribution.”
The Globe and Mail (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Claude Morin, adviser to Quebec premiers and paid RCMP informant, dies at 96
Framed as internally compromised by covert infiltration
[framing_by_emphasis], [loaded_language]
“he was also a paid source of the RCMP. Until then, he had been the epitome of the academic and public servant, a pipe-smoking homebody who liked to putter in the book-lined basement of his suburban house.”
CTV News (Included / Excluded) : Claude Morin, architect of Quebec's Quiet Revolution and RCMP informant, dead at 96
Quebec sovereignty movement portrayed as intellectually legitimate and historically significant
[framing_by_emphasis] and [balanced_reporting]: The article emphasizes Morin’s foundational intellectual role in the Quiet Revolution and sovereignty movement before introducing controversy, framing the cause as serious and nation-building.
“Claude Morin, architect of the Quiet Revolution who helped shape modern Quebec but whose political career unravelled in controversy, has died at 96.”
The Globe and Mail (Included / Excluded) : With summer break and fall election looming, Quebec’s new Premier tries to make her mark
Opposition parties framed as dismissive and obstructive rather than offering alternative vision
[balanced_reporting] While opposition voices are included, they are presented primarily as skeptical and reactive (e.g., calling actions 'tactics'), subtly marginalizing their legitimacy in contrast to the Premier’s proactive framing.
“Charles Milliard, who took over as provincial Liberal Leader in February, dismissed the move as a “political tactic,” and accused the CAQ of “manipulating” Quebeckers on questions of identity.”
The Globe and Mail (Effective / Failing) : Alexandre Boulerice, NDP’s only Quebec MP, leaving for provincial politics, sources say
framed as a weakened and floundering party
The article emphasizes QS's low polling numbers and internal divisions, describing it as 'unable to make gains in popular support' and noting it may lose seats, framing it as ineffective
“Québec Solidaire has been unable to make gains in popular support since then.”
CBC (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Alexandre Boulerice, NDP's sole Quebec MP, to leave party and run provincially: sources
Québec Solidaire is subtly framed as less credible due to poor polling performance
The inclusion of polling data showing QS at 10% and lagging behind other parties introduces questions about the party’s viability and public trust, despite no explicit criticism
“The seat has consistently voted QS since 2012, but the party has lagged in the polls recently.”