Civil Protest
Date Range
Score Range
BBC News (Safe / Threatened) : Eurovision: Israel's Noam Bettan 'shocked' by semi-final protests
Protests framed as disruptive and threatening to order
The article emphasizes the removal of protesters and disruption to performance, using passive language about their removal without exploring their safety or rights. This frames protest as a threat to event security rather than legitimate political expression.
“Several audience members - including one with "Free Palestine" written across his chest - were removed from Vienna's Wiener Stadthalle on Tuesday night after chants of "stop the genocide" were heard during the song.”
Fox News (Safe / Threatened) : Platner called PTSD excuse 'bull----' in 2020 post, now cites his own struggle to explain …
implying that left-wing activism and protest are linked to violent extremism
By associating Platner’s online rhetoric with justifications for political violence and extremist symbols, the article indirectly frames progressive civil protest movements as potentially radicalized or dangerous.
“Platner, a Marine and Army veteran and oyster farmer, wrote in a social media post.”
CBC (Included / Excluded) : No apology included in proposed $30M settlement for Christian Brothers abuse case
survivors' demands for acknowledgment framed as excluded from settlement terms
Survivors' calls for an apology are contrasted with the legal settlement that lacks one, suggesting their emotional and moral诉求 are sidelined in favor of financial resolution.
“But the proposed settlement agreement does not include an apology.”
New York Post (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Beagles rescued from research lab arrive in California as SF activist faces felony charges
Activist civil disobedience framed as criminal and illegitimate
[framing_by_emphasis], [cherry_picking]
“Four of us are facing felony charges for rescuing beagles before they were released to adoption groups last week.”
Sky News (Safe / Threatened) : Israel qualifies for Eurovision Song Contest final
Protests framed as threatening to event safety
The article references a prior stage interruption attempt and notes 'a lot of controversy', implying ongoing security risks, while downplaying the small size of actual demonstrations.
“an interruption attempt during Israel's 2025 performance at Eurovision, when two protesters unsuccessfully attempted to storm the stage and throw paint”
ABC News (Included / Excluded) : Super Bowl halftime performer who ran with a protest flag is found guilty of resisting …
Protest is framed as exclusionary and disruptive rather than legitimate expression
The headline and narrative emphasize the act of running with a 'protest flag' and resisting arrest, using loaded language that frames the protest as an intrusion into a major public event. The omission of context about the 'Free Gaza' or Sudan message removes legitimacy from the protest, implicitly marginalizing its message.
“Super Bowl halftime performer who ran with a protest flag is found guilty of resisting an officer”
New York Post (Included / Excluded) : Israel protesters yanking Jewish woman's hair, pointing strobe light in Orthodox boy's face during wild …
Palestinian solidarity protesters excluded from legitimacy and framed as disruptive outsiders
Omission of protest organizers' perspectives and use of anonymous law enforcement sources marginalize the political nature of the protest, reducing it to disorder.
“Both protests were organized by the activist group Pal-Awda NY/NJ, which promoted the rallies with slogans such as, “No settlers on stolen land” and, “Stop the sale of stolen Palestinian land.””
New York Post (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Stephen A. Smith has made his Shannon Sharpe intentions clear to ESPN
Legal allegations minimized through vague reporting, undermining legitimacy of accusers' claims
[loaded_language], [omission], [vague_attribution]
“Most of the lawsuit was resolved in September.”
9News Australia (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Dezi Freeman's landlord reveals he helped wounded police officer
Anti-authority sentiment framed as legitimate response to systemic failure
[editorializing] and [omission] — The Swifts’ claim that the confrontation could have ended differently 'if protocol and common sense, decency, humanity and reason had … been employed' implies police actions lacked legitimacy, subtly legitimizing Freeman’s resistance.
“the confrontation could have ended differently if "protocol and common sense, decency, humanity and reason had … been employed on that day"”
New York Post (Stable / Crisis) : At least 3 arrested after anti-Israel mob clashes with counter-protesters near NYC synagogue
Protest events framed as recurring crises threatening public order
The article draws a direct parallel to a prior protest ('whirlwind demonstration mirrored another protest'), emphasizing disruption and violence, while highlighting institutional responses like buffer zone laws, amplifying a sense of ongoing crisis.
“The whirlwind demonstration mirrored another protest that wreaked havoc at the historic Park East Synagogue in Manhattan on May 5.”