Medical Safety
Date Range
Score Range
RNZ (Effective / Failing) : Why ultra-processed foods are so addictive
The food environment is framed as failing to protect consumers from harmful products
Cherry-picking of negative health outcomes and omission of regulatory or individual mitigation strategies
“Obesity, heart disease, depression and cancer are just a few examples of the many conditions that have been linked to eating high amounts of UPFs.”
Daily Mail (Stable / Crisis) : Rudy Giuliani reveals he had 'significant spiritual experience' while in coma as he opens up …
Framed as a life-threatening medical emergency requiring extraordinary intervention
[framing_by_emphasis], [vague_attribution]: Focus on ICU, ventilator, last rites, and 'miracle' recovery inflates the event into a dramatic crisis, overshadowing routine medical reporting.
“So severe was his condition that Giuliani required a mechanical ventilator and a priest visited him to read him his last rites last Monday.”
ABC News Australia (Trustworthy / Corrupt) : Sydney doctor Andrew Small charged with alleged sexual assault of patients
Medical profession framed as compromised by a trusted doctor allegedly abusing power
[framing_by_emphasis], [proper_attribution]
“one of the alleged victims has told police she went to Dr Small for stomach pain and was sexually assaulted”
ABC News Australia (Safe / Threatened) : Sydney doctor Andrew Small charged with alleged sexual assault of patients
Patients portrayed as endangered by a medical professional in a position of trust
[framing_by_emphasis], [proper_attribution]
“These are offences committed by a person in a position of trust, a doctor working on patients”
Irish Times (Effective / Failing) : Dáil rejects Social Democrats abortion reform Bill
framed as failing due to outdated waiting periods and criminal penalties
[cherry_picking] focuses on lack of medical basis for waiting period; [omission] omits recent operational improvements like remote consultations
“The mandatory three-day waiting period continues to create unnecessary distress and delay despite having absolutely no medical basis.”
New York Post (Safe / Threatened) : Enhanced Games want to make performance-enhancing drugs mainstream — and they’re coming to Vegas
The omission of known health risks frames medical safety as secondary to performance gains
The article fails to mention cardiovascular, hormonal, or psychological risks of long-term PED use, thereby downplaying threats to athlete well-being.
CBC (Safe / Threatened) : Israeli attacks on medics in southern Lebanon part of 'alarming pattern,' says MSF
Medical personnel and facilities are portrayed as under direct and ongoing threat
The article emphasizes repeated attacks on medics and rescue teams, using MSF's characterization of an 'alarming pattern' and detailing specific incidents where paramedics were killed while responding to calls. The framing centers on the vulnerability of health workers despite their protected status under international law.
“International organization Doctors Without Borders says a Tuesday drone strike that killed two paramedics and injured another in southern Lebanon is part of an "alarming pattern" of Israeli attacks targeting rescue teams.”
RNZ (Effective / Failing) : Why ultra-processed foods are so addictive
Current food safety and regulatory systems are implied to be failing, allowing addictive products to dominate the market
Omission of regulatory perspectives and emphasis on market dominance of UPFs suggest systemic failure in protecting consumers.
“Seventy percent of packaged foods that sit on our supermarket shelves are ultra processed”
Fox News (Safe / Threatened) : New federal probe examines whether taxpayer dollars fund child gender transitions, legal defenses
gender-affirming care portrayed as inherently dangerous to children
Loaded language and sensationalism frame puberty blockers and hormones as 'dangerous sex-change procedures' without medical context, implying patients are under threat from care rather than protected by it.
“"Health care providers are supposed to protect children’s health, not subject them to dangerous sex-change procedures driven by ideology," Cassidy said in a news release about the new probes.”
The Guardian (Effective / Failing) : Paediatrician in Germany charged with 130 counts of sexual abuse
Frames medical institutions as failing to protect patients due to protocol violations
The article highlights the failure to follow the 'four-eyes protocol', suggesting systemic breakdowns in child protection during medical exams. This implies institutional incompetence despite existing safeguards.
“It had emerged that the “four-eyes protocol”, under which two people must be present during an examination of a child, had not always been respected”