Haiti
Date Range
Score Range
CBC (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Doctors Without Borders forced to evacuate hospital in Haiti's capital as gang violence ramps up
The Haitian government is framed as lacking legitimacy due to inability to ensure security or hold elections
[comprehensive_sourcing], [contextual_completeness]
“Haiti's Prime Minister Alix Didier Fils-Aimé said it was clear the country's insecurity would not allow for elections in August as planned.”
Stuff.co.nz (Effective / Failing) : New gang violence in Haiti displaces hundreds of people
Haitian state institutions are framed as failing to maintain security and public order
The article notes the absence of a president since 2021 and describes the government's response as 'largely insufficient,' indicating institutional collapse.
“Haiti has not had a president since the assassination.”
Reuters (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Hospitals evacuated, MSF services halted as rival gangs clash in Haiti's capital
portrayed as lacking authority and capacity to govern or hold elections
[proper_attribution] (severity 9/10): The Prime Minister’s statement that elections cannot proceed due to insecurity implicitly frames the government as unable to fulfill basic democratic functions, undermining its legitimacy.
“In an interview on Monday, Haiti's Prime Minister Alix Didier Fils-Aime said it was clear Haiti's insecurity would not allow for elections in August as planned. Haiti's last president was murdered in 2021 and it has not held elections since 2016.”
ABC News (Stable / Crisis) : Four people convicted of conspiracy in US trial tied to 2021 assassination of Haiti's president
Haiti is framed as being in a state of ongoing political and social collapse
[framing_by_emphasis] and [omission] — The article emphasizes the aftermath of the assassination as leading to 'unprecedented turmoil' while omitting deeper structural causes or Haitian-led responses, reinforcing a crisis narrative.
“Moïse’s assassination led to unprecedented turmoil in the Caribbean nation, where gang leaders have grown increasingly violent and empowered.”
CTV News (Stable / Crisis) : 4 people convicted of conspiracy in U.S. trial tied to 2021 assassination of Haiti’s president
Haiti is portrayed as陷入持续危机和失控状态
[framing_by_emphasis] and [loaded_language]: The phrase 'extraordinary turmoil' amplifies the situation beyond neutral description, and the emphasis on gang violence and judicial collapse frames Haiti as fundamentally unstable.
“whose death led to extraordinary turmoil in the Caribbean nation”
AP News (Stable / Crisis) : 4 people convicted of conspiracy in US trial tied to 2021 assassination of Haiti’s president
Haiti is framed as陷入 ongoing crisis and instability following the assassination
[framing_by_emphasis] and [editorializing] in lead paragraph amplify the destabilizing impact of the assassination without neutralizing context.
“whose death led to extraordinary turmoil in the Caribbean nation”
The Guardian (Stable / Crisis) : Four south Florida men convicted in Haitian president’s assassination
Haiti is framed as being in a state of political and social collapse following the assassination
[framing_by_emphasis], [loaded_language]
“a killing that left a gaping political vacuum in the Caribbean nation and emboldened powerful gangs.”
Fox News (Stable / Crisis) : Florida jury convicts 4 men who plotted assassination of Haiti's president from South Florida hub
Haiti framed as in ongoing crisis and political collapse
[omission] of counter-narratives and selective emphasis on chaos; article highlights gang control and instability without balancing with governance efforts
“plunged the Caribbean nation into unprecedented gang violence”
The Washington Post (Safe / Threatened) : A Supreme Court justice’s personal ties to Haiti highlight stakes in asylum case
Haiti is framed as severely unsafe and unstable
[loaded_language], [comprehensive_sourcing]
“Haiti is, you know, one of the poorest countries in the Western Hemisphere,” she said in a February 2019 talk at Notre Dame Law School. “And it’s close enough to the United States that we could go as a family and be involved in Haiti as the children got older. So we chose Haiti.”
USA Today (Ally / Adversary) : From legal to hunted: Haitians, Syrians in Supreme Court deportation battle
Haiti and Haitians framed as targets of hostile political rhetoric
The article emphasizes Trump’s false and inflammatory claim that Haitians in Ohio are 'eating the dogs' and 'eating the cats,' presented without sufficient distancing, framing Haitians as scapegoated adversaries.
“In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs”