Free Speech
Date Range
Score Range
The New York Times (Stable / Crisis) : Eating Healthy? No, They’re Eating Biblically.
Wellness culture presented as filling a void left by declining belief systems, implying societal instability
[cherry_picking], [editorializing]
“We don’t have a lot of belief systems left in this country. People are desperate for meaning in their lives.”
The New York Times (Beneficial / Harmful) : N.Y.U. Students Object to Speaker Who Calls Their Generation ‘Coddled’
Free speech is framed as beneficial and essential for student growth
The inclusion of student testimonials who credit Haidt with empowering dialogue and bridge-building frames open discourse as a positive developmental tool.
“Hannah Swartz, a graduating senior who studied psychology, said that he enthusiastically helped her start a group for those interested in bridging divides. “It’s not that he’s blaming our generation for the way we are,” she said. “He’s trying to empower us with the skills to go out in the world.””
The New York Times (Ally / Adversary) : N.Y.U. Students Object to Speaker Who Calls Their Generation ‘Coddled’
Free speech is framed as a constructive force under attack from student activism
The article uses irony and symbolic framing to position Dr. Haidt as a victim of the very 'cancel culture' he critiques, aligning free speech with moral clarity.
“But for Dr. Haidt’s supporters, the symbolism is unmistakable. The controversy might even fit in one of his own books: A small group of students tries to cancel an outspoken critic of cancel culture, who says that American education has been woefully deficient when it comes to exposing young people to perspectives different from their own.”
USA Today (Legitimate / Illegitimate) : Sydney Sweeney OnlyFans plot on 'Euphoria' Season 3 polarizes viewers
Artistic expression in television is framed as illegitimate when it involves sexualized or controversial content
[editorializing], [loaded_language] — Presentation of Kelly’s condemnation without rebuttal frames creative choices as morally unjustifiable
“She also expressed disbelief that Sweeney "agreed to this" and called Levinson "sick" for writing the storyline.”
Fox News (Ally / Adversary) : Meat-only diet followers claim disease reversal as expert says Americans are 'the sickest'
Traditional nutrition science is framed as an adversarial force suppressing truth
[narrative_framing], [vague_attribution]: The article references a 'war on protein' and claims that 'special-interest groups' demonized meat, positioning mainstream nutrition guidance as hostile to dietary freedom.
“Special-interest groups, such as vegan societies, have used Keys' research to 'demonize' meat and perpetrate widespread misconceptions about nutrition, Bryan said.”
The Guardian (Included / Excluded) : Greta Thunberg, Gary Lineker sign letter defending Southbank Centre chair
Framing free speech as under threat and requiring protection from backlash
[balanced_reporting] and [proper_attribution]: The article highlights a letter signed by prominent cultural figures warning of a 'smear campaign' intended to silence critics, positioning free expression as being suppressed.
““The purpose of the smear campaign, which we repeat is entirely without foundation in fact, is to traduce and marginalise Misan,” reads the letter. “And it is intended to send a message to others that if they speak out, they will be subject to harassment and threats.””
Daily Mail (Included / Excluded) : Theatre cancels comedian Roy 'Chubby' Brown's 'No Offence Meant' show... because it does not promote …
Free speech is being framed as excluded or suppressed
The article emphasizes the cancellation of a comedian's show under the banner of 'inclusion', while amplifying the comedian's critique of the decision. Loaded language and narrative framing position free expression as being sidelined in favor of institutional values, implying marginalization of certain artistic voices.
“Wouldn't the sensible thing, if the new management has an issue for any reason with the Chubby show, have been to honour the contracted booking and let the show go ahead?”
NBC News (Included / Excluded) : Comey says DOJ must be the ‘guardian’ of U.S. principles of justice
Framed as under threat from state retaliation against critics
The article emphasizes Comey’s warning that Trump critics should prepare to be targeted, suggesting a chilling effect on free expression. This positions free speech as being excluded or punished.
“I think we should all be prepared that they will continue to use the power of the Justice Department to please Donald Trump and try to meet his desire for retribution against people who have spoken out.”
Sky News (Included / Excluded) : Barcelona boss Hansi Flick reacts after Lamine Yamal waves Palestinian flag at La Liga victory …
Free expression in sports is being marginalized
[cherry_picking] and [omission] - The article omits broader support for athlete activism and focuses only on Flick's disapproval, framing symbolic expression as controversial rather than legitimate.
“This, I don't normally like. I spoke with him. I said if he wants this, it is his decision. He is old enough. He's 18 years old.”
Daily Mail (Included / Excluded) : Billy Bob Thornton blasts celebrities who use their platform to talk about politics as he …
The right of celebrities to express political views is subtly marginalized, suggesting such speech should be excluded from mainstream cultural platforms
Cherry-picking and omission suppress voices that defend civic expression by public figures. By presenting only skeptical viewpoints without counterbalance, the article implies that political speech at award shows is out of place, thus excluding it from accepted norms of discourse.